Latest ed news

What’s the relationship between education, income, and favoring the Pakistani Taliban?

By webfeeds.brookings.edu
Published On :: Mon, 19 Oct 2015 10:28:00 -0400

The narratives on U.S. development aid to Pakistan—as well as Pakistan’s own development policy discussion—frequently invoke the conventional wisdom that more education and better economic opportunities result in lower extremism. In the debate surrounding the Kerry-Lugar-Berman bill in 2009, for instance, the late Ambassador Richard Holbrooke urged Congress to “target the economic and social roots of extremism in western Pakistan with more economic aid.”

But evidence across various contexts, including in Pakistan, has not supported this notion (see Alan Kreuger’s What Makes a Terrorist for a good overview of this evidence). We know that many terrorists are educated. And lack of education and economic opportunities do not appear to drive support for terrorism and terrorist groups. I have argued that we need to focus on the quality and content of the educational curricula—in Pakistan’s case, they are rife with biases and intolerance, and designed to foster an exclusionary identity—to understand the relationship between education and attitudes toward extremism.

My latest analysis with data from the March 2013 Pew Global Attitudes poll conducted in Pakistan sheds new light on the relationship between years of education and Pakistanis’ views of the Taliban, and lends supports to the conventional wisdom. The survey sampled 1,201 respondents throughout Pakistan, except the most insecure areas of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Baluchistan. This was a time of mounting terror attacks by the Pakistani Taliban (a few months after their attack on Malala), and came at the tail end of the Pakistan People's Party’s term in power, before the May 2013 general elections.

On attitudes toward the Pakistani Taliban, or Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), 3 percent of respondents to the Pew poll said they had a very favorable view, 13 percent reported somewhat favorable views, while nearly 17 percent and 39 percent answered that they had somewhat unfavorable and very unfavorable views, respectively. A large percentage of respondents (28 percent) chose not to answer the question or said they did not know their views. This is typical with a sensitive survey question such as this one, in a context as insecure as Pakistan.

So overall levels of support for the TTP are low, and the majority of respondents report having unfavorable views. The non-responses could reflect those who have unfavorable views but choose not to respond because of fear, or those who may simply not have an opinion on the Pakistani Taliban.

The first part of my analysis cross-tabulates attitudes toward the TTP with education and income respectively. I look at the distribution of attitudes for each education and income category (with very and somewhat favorable views lumped together as favorable; similarly for unfavorable attitudes).

Figure 1. Pakistani views on the Pakistani Taliban, by education level, 2013

Figure 1 shows that an increasing percentage of respondents report unfavorable views of the Taliban as education levels rise; and there is a decreasing percentage of non-responses at higher education levels (suggesting that more educated people have more confidence in their views, stronger views, or less fear). However, the percentage of respondents with favorable views of the Taliban, hovering between 10-20 percent, is not that different across education levels, and does not vary monotonically with education.

Figure 2. Pakistani views on the Pakistani Taliban, by income level, 2013

Figure 2 shows views on the Pakistani Taliban by income level. While the percentage of non-responses is highest for the lowest income category, the percentages responding favorably and unfavorably do not change monotonically with income. We see broadly similar distributions of attitudes across the four income levels.

But these cross-tabulations do not account for other factors that may affect attitudes: age, gender, and geographical location. Regressions (not shown here) accounting for these factors in addition to income and education show interesting results: relative to no education, higher education levels are associated with less favorable opinions of the Pakistani Taliban; these results are strongest for those with some university education, which is heartening. This confirms findings from focus groups I conducted with university students in Pakistan in May 2015. Students at public universities engaged in wide ranging political and social debates with each other on Pakistan and its identity, quoted Rousseau and Chomsky, and had more nuanced views on terrorism and the rest of the world relative to high school students I interviewed. This must at least partly be a result of the superior curriculum and variety of materials to which they are exposed at the college level.

My regressions also show that older people have more unfavorable opinions toward the Taliban, relative to younger people; this is concerning and is consistent with the trend toward rising extremist views in Pakistan’s younger population. The problems in Pakistan’s curriculum that began in the 1980s are likely to be at least partly responsible for this trend. Urban respondents seem to have more favorable opinions toward the Taliban than rural respondents; respondents from Punjab and Baluchistan have more favorable opinions toward the Taliban relative to those from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, which as a province has had a closer and more direct experience with terror. The regression shows no relationship of income with attitudes, as was suggested by Figure 2.

Overall, the Pew 2013 data show evidence of a positive relationship between more education and lack of support for the Taliban, suggesting that the persisting but increasingly discredited conventional wisdom on these issues may hold some truth after all. These results should be complemented with additional years of data. That is what I will work on next.

What’s the relationship between education, income, and favoring the Pakistani Taliban?

Figure 1. Pakistani views on the Pakistani Taliban, by education level, 2013

Figure 2. Pakistani views on the Pakistani Taliban, by income level, 2013

Authors

Brazil gripped by major political crisis in midst of Covid-19 pandemic

Brazil: an isolated, crisis-ridden and aimless government – Bolsonaro out!

Venezuela: more mercenaries arrested including two US special forces veterans

Micro-community of tiny homes flourishes on rehabilitated vacant lot

FedEx to test Nissan's electric e-NV200 delivery van in Washington DC area

Washington, DC predicted to sink 6 inches or more by 2100

Great protected bike lanes are popping up in Washington DC (video)

Will autonomous delivery robots soon be pushing pedestrians off the sidewalks?

First residential building certified to the Fitwel standard

Jacques Tati's film Playtime was released 50 years ago, but has lessons for us today

A tall tale of a telephone pole, or why pedestrians can't have a nice place to walk

100 years ago a flu pandemic started, killing as many as 100 million

Why are so many visions of the future dominated by cars?

100 years ago, food helped win the war

Why we have regulations: So people don't get buried in molasses

Finnish passenger ferry retrofits rotary sail to reduce emissions

From bike lanes to solar, the UK has transformed itself since 2006

Ecotricity launches wind- and solar-powered cell phone network

Photo: Red fox shows its true colors

Photo: White-tailed jackrabbit is a noble being

Thrift stores are tired of getting people's useless junk

6 habits that keep me organized

Another Reason We Need the Smart Grid: Record Heat

Automated electricity bill payments cause people to consume more energy

A major U.S. utility company just pledged to go carbon-free for the first time in American history

Forget bike lanes, we need Protected Mobility Lanes

6 beauty recipes that are pink and red for Valentine's Day

Wretched Excess Never Looked So Good: 45,000 Lights On A Single House

IBS Home Gets LEED Points, But Misses the Green Point

Wretched Excess Dept: Castor Design's Marble with Fluorescent Tube

Just what we needed Dept: The Pet Treat Maker

Wretched Excess or the future of housing design? Another look at the car elevator

Heated glass: Could this be the least sustainable building product ever invented?

Dubious Dubai: World's largest air conditioned city to be built, covering 48 million square feet

Wretched Excess or Clever Design? Apartment tower with car elevators is definitely the former.

Wretched excess comes to the summer kitchen

Wretched Excess: Private yachts are so yesterday, now it's private floating islands.

Just what we needed dept: a $10,000 home pizza oven

The Coffeeboxx: Wretched excess or clever design?

Just what we needed dept: The pre-peeled, plastic-packed orange

How to Go Green: Wedding Engagement

Cadbury's Dairy Milk Goes Fairtrade, Next Billion Go To TED, Huff Post on Coal, and More

TranquiliT Adds Something Green to Your Wedding With Eco-Friendly Bridal Gowns

Planet Green's Ultimate Green Wedding Guide

Green Your Wedding! Low Cost, Zero-Waste, Eco-Conscious Options

Holy Crap! Toilet-Paper Wedding Dress Displays Unparalleled Dedication

5 Ridiculously Over-the-Top, Extravagant Celebrity Weddings

Win an Eco-Friendly, Solar-Powered Wedding

Beautiful Bike Wedding in Sao Paulo

The Finish Line: Backwrapping vs. Edgewrapping

The Finish Line: Foam Shapes Revisited

Green Globes vs. LEED

Cloaked in Green?

EPDs, HPDs and Red Lists (Oh My)!

LED Lighting is the Future

Anti-LEED Legislation

Alternatives to LEED

Green Advocacy vs. Informed Consent

Will LEED v4 Ever Be Usable?

Is a LEED Building Healthy?

Embodied Energy of Building Materials

Is LEED Just a Fad?

NCS Trust ‘sad and disappointed’ at government plans to shut it down

Next chair of the National Lottery Community Fund revealed

Subscribe To Our Newsletter